Failure is not an option

Part 2

The shame behind the culture of “Failure is not an option”

05/24/2024

So what happens when failure becomes a part of our being; when it soaks in, takes root and leaves us questioning “how can I have value when everything inside of me says that with each failure I become less than I was before”? We measure ourselves against the standard of perfection, acknowledging with our heads that perfection is unobtainable, but in our hearts, struggling in the heat of the moment to accept nothing less than perfection in the areas that matter.

But what are the areas that matter?

Whenever you feel the pressure is on and the stakes are high, you’re most likely dealing in an area that matters to you. In these areas, failure has a direct impact on how you view yourself. The result is a powerful response that produces anxiety and stress. Each failure in the same area works hand in hand with past failures, reinforcing your reaction if you do not interrupt the process. It is a debilitating merry-go-round that drains you of hope, impedes your ability to see value within yourself and leaves you more susceptible to this response with each trip around.

This response is shame.

There is a difference between the guilt of recognizing an action we’ve taken runs contrary to our moral compass, and shame that tells us that a mistake or error in judgment is evidence of our poor character and value.  Guilt serves a purpose.  It redirects us towards behaving in a manner that is consistent with what we believe is right.  Shame though, serves no purpose.  It is only destructive.

Guilt says “I failed” where shame says “I am a failure”.

Failure is not a four-letter word.  It serves as a guide – an educator.  We learn far more from our failures than our successes.  One of my favorite children’s movies is Disney’s Meet the Robinsons.  Without spoiling the story in case you’ve not seen it, the main character struggles with shame around the idea of failure, but is challenged to see failure as a pathway to success.  This is where the thought of “failure is not an option” can be so destructive.  Failure guides us towards success rather than discouraging us from continuing.  In the end, regardless of if we accomplish our intended objective, we discover we have gained strength, courage, resilience and, surprisingly, confidence.

But there will always be the doubters, not the least of which is your inner-critic.  Those who would wag their tongues and judge you for their perceptions of how you have fallen short.  In the Internet culture, the ability to state anonymous opinions has led to an explosion of judgment and insensitivity.  No longer is bullying limited to the playground and obnoxious bosses.  It is a breeding ground for shame and true vulnerability because failure is ruthlessly punished.  This gives fuel to our inner-critic who is off to the races if we are not equipped to address these attacks on our worth and value.

 

So why try to succeed in the face of failure if in doing so we draw the attention of those eager to attack us with their venom?

 

This is a common sentiment I see.  The risk just feels too great.  Our doubters, especially the one living inside of our heads, have gained our submission and we find ourselves frozen.  Our belief is that action invites criticism, so it is safer to not act at all.  I love what Theodore Roosevelt has to say about this topic.  He recognized the value in risking for a personally valued cause.  He saw the critics for what all critics are - detached and uninvested in the person striving to accomplish.  These are not allies looking to help us grow, but faceless critics who surface from the shadows to state selfish opinions.  As Roosevelt articulately expressed…

It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles, or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood; who strives valiantly; who errs, who comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds; who knows great enthusiasms, the great devotions; who spends himself in a worthy cause; who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory nor defeat.”

 Every action brings risk.  But every action is also an opportunity to step towards growth and fulfillment.  Failure does not define us, but it does shape us.  If we interpret our value through the lens of failure, we surrender our inherent value – the value we were born with – as if we actually had the power to change that value.  Surrendering our value simply leads us to deny who we are in the same way that we can deny that the sky is blue and the sun is warm.  If we instead choose to fight to embrace our value - and it is a fight - we provide ourselves the opportunity to grow towards a life far more fulfilling than one that requires the pointless perfection of never failing.